BSP – Blundered Sale Post-Mortem

by Crispin Fernandez, MD

| Photo by Jingming Pan on Unsplash

In March 2025, the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) sold 24.95 metric tons of gold, which represented approximately 32.5% of its total gold holdings at the time.

According to the World Gold Council, BSP held approximately 76.7 metric tons of gold before the sale. The sale of 24.95 tons from total holdings before the sale of 76.7 tons amounts to [(24.95 ÷ 76.7)] 32.5% of total holdings. This makes BSP the largest gold seller among central banks in the first half of 2025, while most other countries were net buyers.

In March 2025, the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas sold 24.95 metric tons of gold at prices ranging from $2,338 to $2,427 per ounce, citing “active reserve management” amid global uncertainty. Seven months later, gold has surged past $4,058 per ounce, and the Philippines is left reckoning with a sobering reality: liquidating a strategic asset at a discount, while the rest of the world was buying.

At BSP’s sale price, the gold fetched roughly $1.88 billion. At today’s market rate, the same tonnage would be worth $3.26 billion—a staggering $1.38 billion opportunity loss. This isn’t just a spreadsheet error. It’s a sovereign misstep with generational consequences.

While BSP was offloading bullion, China, Turkey, India, and Russia were quietly accumulating. The World Gold Council reported that central banks were net buyers in Q1 and Q2 of 2025, viewing gold as a hedge against inflation, geopolitical risk, and dollar volatility. Even smaller economies, such as Singapore and Poland, expanded their reserves, signaling long-term confidence in gold’s role as a stabilizer.

So why did the Philippines zig when others zagged?

The BSP has not disclosed the buyers—standard practice in over-the-counter (OTC) bullion markets. But this opacity raises questions. Were the buyers sovereign funds? Private banks? Other central banks? And what trade commissions, if any, were paid to intermediaries? In a country where every peso counts, the lack of transparency surrounding the disposal of a multi-billion-dollar asset is troubling.

BSP officials cited “portfolio rebalancing” and “profit-taking” amid high prices. At the time, gold hovered near record highs, and the GIR (Gross International Reserves) stood firm. But this logic collapses under hindsight. March wasn’t a peak—it was a plateau. The surge to $4,000+ was foreseeable, driven by escalating geopolitical tensions (Ukraine, Taiwan, the Middle East), global rate cuts, a softening dollar, and central bank diversification away from the USD.

“The BSP has not disclosed the buyers—standard practice in over-the-counter (OTC) bullion markets. But this opacity raises questions. Were the buyers sovereign funds? Private banks? Other central banks? And what trade commissions, if any, were paid to intermediaries? “

If BSP’s sale was tactical, it lacked strategic foresight. If it was pressured—by liquidity needs, debt servicing, or political timing—it demands scrutiny. This isn’t just about gold. It’s about sovereign asset governance. The Philippines needs a public registry of strategic asset movements, including gold, foreign currency, and special drawing rights; congressional oversight of GIR disposal, especially during election years or fiscal stress; a sovereign asset timing dashboard, simulating sale scenarios, opportunity costs, and global benchmarks; and disclosure of counterparties and commissions, anonymized if necessary but audited for integrity.

Compounding this blunder is the overall BOP position for 2025, now expected to post a $ 6.9 billion deficit, or 1.4% of the gross domestic product (GDP), wider than its initial forecast of $6.3 billion, or 1.3% of the GDP.

BSP also adjusted its 2026 forecast to a $3.4 billion deficit, or 0.6% of GDP, in 2026, from the $2.8 billion deficit, or 0.5% of GDP, it reported in the second quarter.

“These reflect a widening trade-in-goods gap, subdued services receipts, and restrained capital inflows amid global uncertainty and shifting trade policies,” the BSP accompanying statement said.

The payments position takes into account Philippine transactions with the rest of the world during a specific period. A surplus means more funds entered the country, while a deficit means more funds exited. The flow of goods, investment earnings, and foreign aid — also known as the current account — is expected to post a $16.4 billion deficit this year, slightly higher than the $16.3 billion deficit projected in the second quarter of 2023.

The BSP said, “Goods exports and imports are anticipated to remain sluggish, shaped by softening global demand, easing commodity prices, and tempered domestic growth momentum”.

“Growth in services exports, particularly in business process outsourcing (BPO) and tourism, is expected to moderate as the sector contends with uncertainties surrounding US reshoring policies and weakening inbound travel,” it added.

Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) data show that the balance of trade in goods posted a $3.540 billion deficit in August, narrower than the $4.422 billion deficit in July and the $4.395 billion deficit in August 2024.

“Infrastructure investments, potential trade diversion, and efforts to diversify export and import partners may help cushion external shocks. However, structural constraints, such as logistical inefficiencies, skills mismatches, and elevated input costs, continue to weigh on export competitiveness,” the BSP said.

The central bank also expects foreign direct and portfolio investment inflows to soften from 2024, reflecting “heightened” global financial volatility and cautious investor behavior. However, it sees policy reforms, such as amendments to the Investors’ Lease Act, as improving the investment climate.

Gold isn’t just a commodity. It’s a sign of prudent governance. In a world of fiat fragility and geopolitical flux, it anchors trust. The BSP’s March sale may have been legal, but was it wise? And who benefits when a nation sells low while others buy high?

The gold that got away isn’t just bullion; it’s also a symbol of the past. It’s a metaphor for missed strategy, opaque governance, and the urgent need for reform.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Dr. Crispin Fernandez advocates for overseas Filipinos, public health, transformative political change, and patriotic economics. He is also a community organizer, leader, and freelance writer.

You may also like

Leave a Comment