Debt or more Debt: the Chinese Debt Trap – A Laos epic sequel unfolding in the Philippines (1980s – 2023)

by Crispin Fernandez, MD

| Photo by Towfiqu Barbhuiya on Unsplash

Millions of textile workers in Pakistan have been laid off because the country has too much foreign debt and had to choose between paying foreign loans or keeping the electricity on and the machines that run on electricity. Sri Lanka defaulted on foreign loans a year ago, losing around 500,000 jobs and 50% inflation. The government of Kenya was unable to pay its workers to save enough foreign exchange to pay back foreign loans to avoid default and dire consequences.

These countries, Zambia and Mongolia, struggled to keep their social safety nets and other services going because revenues were funneled into debt payments to an unforgiving debtor – China.

China has been hesitant to forgive or restructure nor provide transparency into the size of the underwritten loans; ambiguous loan agreements push debtor nations to place China loans ahead of other loans and their own government services. With a lack of transparency, different lenders have been unwilling to provide relief, particularly with the probability that subsequent loans become subject to being junior to the China loans. The loans boosted those nations’ economies but raised foreign interest payments so high that its government was forced to cut subsidies for farmers, healthcare, education, and welfare schemes.

The 2024 Philippine budget is 40% debt-driven and adds around 2% to the GDP. Php125B of earnings from the LandBank, DBP, and other government-owned and controlled corporations like PAGCOR – previously used for social development and the general appropriations are Ching diverted to the Maharlika Investment Fund.

In his State of the Nation address in 1980, President Marcos Sr. spoke of a national budget that contained a structural deficit of 1/7 of the total – the latest 2024 General Appropriations Bill includes borrowing that is 40% of the total. While most of the borrowing will help add around 2% to the GDP, the lion’s share of that wealth will accrue not to the marginalized of society. Marcos Sr. also boasted of trebling the minimum wage from the earlier decade to the next.

“To our political leadership and the ruling elite, we appeal – make haste and reform the person in the mirror – be the change. Epiphany is far better than unintended consequences.”

The minimum wage was Php 466 in 2013. In 2023, it is P610 – a mere 76% increase from a decade ago. Clearly, the current administration cannot make the same claim of trebling the minimum wage – of course, the financial team under Sec. Diokno cannot be blamed for what they inherited, but they can be blamed for what happens through 2028.

Policy failures must not lead to greater income inequality. It is not enough to exempt minimum wage from income taxes – it is high time for an earned income tax credit to enable the working poor to sustain daily subsistence and accumulate some wealth with those whose wealth is far beyond their imagination.

Savings create investment; failing that, it establishes consumption, which, if managed well, will generate more commerce and industry, creating organic growth in jobs, increasing tax collection, and reducing foreign borrowing, which grows the gross international reserves. Dare we dream that with more employment, there will be less need for deploying our manpower overseas. Economics 101.

Unfortunately, greed and the resulting corruption prevail, and our society’s elite remain oblivious to an impending catastrophe borne out of a people growing ever more impatient and desperate by the day. The time for reform is now. To our political leadership and the ruling elite, we appeal – make haste and reform the person in the mirror – be the change. Epiphany is far better than unintended consequences.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Dr. Crispin Fernandez advocates for overseas Filipinos, public health, transformative political change, and patriotic economics. He is also a community organizer, leader, and freelance writer.

You may also like

Leave a Comment